Showing posts with label Stimulus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stimulus. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Adaptive Programs


You can write programs that are linear, and always do the same thing with inputs. Or, you can write programs that run in infinite loops, and spend hours of your life debugging them. Hey, back in the 1980s when faced with what kind of computer science I should study, I stayed away from those hot new topics like Artificial Intelligence. Where you could write adaptive programs, like "Eliza", that you could talk to, and they could understand you, and adapt to you.

So how do you debug a President? This one produces the same policy output no matter the circumstances. Spent this morning reading President Obama's FY 2013 budget. Sort of an addictive habit (plus people just want to know what is buried in there)..

More stimulus - same old recycled policies from last year, the $$ to teachers and first responders. $$ for infrastructure like high speed rail, and affordable health care. $$ to Democratic voters (oops, being redundant).

So where is the President who is adaptive, like a computer program that reacts to new situations in new ways? The one, you know, who represents all Americans? Is there any hope for this?

Saturday, September 17, 2011

The Seeds are Always There

It was called a failure of imagination.
It was called a failure to connect the dots.

When you enter politics, do these things, part of the human condition (didn't we all grow up playing dots in Calculus class..) go by the wayside?

Back in 9/11, say on 9/10/2001.. or even back in the Last Millenium which seems so long ago, even the street numbers have been changed since then. There were seeds. There were transcripts from bin Laden and friends. Statements that could lead you to imagine using aircraft as weapons of mass destruction. There were dots, unconnected, between the foreign surveillance apparatus, and domestic criminal intelligence. Alas the data systems did not talk to each other. But even back in the 1980s people were talking about data matching. When you enter civil service, as with politics, does your ability to connect dots and use your imagination go by the wayside too?

Today's imagination/dot exercise is the federal budget. Mr Elmendorf, head of the Congressional Budget Office, testifying in front of the Super Committee. In case you aren't able to listen to cspan at work (I am so totally lucky!) it is rebroadcast today on cspan radio. The non-partisan CBO chief says that if we continue on with current policies - those Bush tax cuts, those emergency unemployment compensation benefits, that doc fix which allows Medicare doctors to have full reimbursement.. That we are looking at an unsustainable situation, with spending beyond control and at something like 190% of GDP in the decades to come.

20% to 40% to 100% to 190%, its starting to be like trillions to me, and become somewhat meaningless. As my federal friends would say, after enough shutdown "deadlines" come and go and the world goes on, you tend to get numb to these things.

So what kind of imagination and dot drawing is needed today, and how do we inspire our elected representatives and civil servants to partake in this exercise?

Mr Elmendorf says there is no free lunch. That should be Rule #1. Deal with Problems Now. OK those benefiting from those tax cuts, the word "temporary" means they are going to end. And how long can an emergency exist, to keep providing unemployment to the non-working class. Doc fix, or county timber payments. Things tend to last forever. Till they don't.

I like the word "nexus". If Medicare is going to continue, let it pay for itself. Maybe every doctor and every patient needs to get a "haircut" as they call it in the financial world. The next world for the US will of course be national health insurance, like every other civilized nation on the planet. So if your heart is in it, and you practice medicine not for the degrees on your wall and the vacations in Bora Bora, then you'll stick with it.

Rule #2. Lets think about Obama's pitch for a second stimulus, to fund construction workers, teachers, fire fighters. How the typical Democratic pitch for public sector job creation has a stimulating effect on the economy. Lets do the math. A $45K public sector job may generate $3,150 back to the state in the form of income tax (using a 7% effective marginal tax rate). And $9,900 back to the feds in the form of federal income tax (using a 22% effective marginal tax rate). So - for $45,000 worth of expenditure, you reap back $13,050 in terms of income tax. Whoa! Even a refrigerator is more efficient than that. And where does the $45,000 come from - the federal taxes of other working people.

Why is it hard to see that having survived Stimulus 1 (almost, nearly) that to invest in Stimulus 2 doesn't really pay off. Is the way to grow the economy really up to the venture capitalists and innovators in the world, and the government can't really do it all (answer left as an exercise to the reader - look up the efficiency of refrigerators). Does that really require a leap of imagination, or a dot exercise? Please send a dot template, with instructions, to your local elected representatives, and ask them to participate.

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Faithful to the Scavenger Hunt..

Some people go on fun scavenger hunts. The geocaching thing - which connects people who aren't connected in any way, except they like to find things. When they find them, a good use of the advanced technology in their smartphone, hence justifying the cost of a data plan and GPS satellites too.. they leave a trace behind.

Like inside a lamppost (there is an inside to a lamppost? trust me, I've seen it! at least in Virginia they have insides..), you open it up. You find a small vial. You open that up. You look inside. You do not have to issue any secret spells or even chant xyzzy (or even have it on your license plate). You can write your own special "I was here, or, should your name be Kilroy say, 'Kilroy was here' ".

But us grownups have other types of scavenger hunts. Today was tracking little pieces of information for OMB reporting. How fun is that! Lots of little pieces of evidence, without even the wisdom of a smartphone (except to keep me going with zumba dance tunes!) I learned much today in this quest.

Much of it unprintable. But the public things - like a vendor who did a portion of our stimulus-funded project. How there are vendors in Oregon who have their headquarters on Park Avenue in New York City. Sounds pretty tony to me. But hey, its on that price list, so apparently all is cool and we aren't paying too much.

Now why it is important to report on the congressional district of this vendor's headquarters is beyond me. Its not even Anthony Weiner's district, which I believe will get vaporized due to population loss in the non-garden state, but someone named Carolyn Maloney. NY14. I am finally getting the hang of this district numbering system. Sort of a prep for the 2012 elections.

Stimulus #1, remember that? Some of us are still faithfully tracking the money and jobs created. I was able to faithfully report 4.36 jobs were funded last quarter. OMB cares, and they get reports from all faithful scavenger reporters. Every i dotted, every t crossed. That is I hope. Everyone else has completely and absolutely lost interest. Or perhaps they trust me, yes thats it.

Sunday, June 12, 2011

The Corners of My Car

Ah, it is already raining. So forget about washing the car (I can't make it rain, today). Cleaning out the corners of my car, 27 hundred water bottles (returnable! worth 5cents each!) I wish a band crew would come around and take them from me, but alas, they will now sit in bags in the garage, till they reach a critical mass (when we can't get past them to the lawnmower).

Also found, a little postit of things to do today, from days gone by: FY 09 budget, FY 10 budget. Has it always been thus? Are we always stuck between this federal fiscal year, and the next federal fiscal year? Right now we are at last content (or, have settled) on a FY 11 budget, and still fussing over a FY 12 budget.

What else was unearthed.. chile-cheese fritos. Ah, I remember those Stimulus Point of Contact meetings. I remember when it was a big thrill to attend those, with the movers and shakers. Back when the federal Stimulus held real promise - money to lift us out of recession! Put people to work!

And when federal data doesn't show the results, they change the reporting rules. Instead of cumulatively counting how many jobs were created or saved (tricky), it becomes a snapshot - only those jobs funded this quarter. Count every last piece - even if a research analyst only worked for 10 minutes, capture this in the jobs total. ok.

Back in the heyday people cared about the Stimulus and such things. While perhaps the most fun thing was getting a bag of chile cheese fritos at the Capital Market on State Street, a familiar place that always smelled like fried food. You could always park there at the end of the day and no one would care, there would be spaces for the taking. Though I miss the monthly interaction with the owner of the market in making my (cheap) parking payment, he always politely responded "thank you lady" with a smile.

Now its more like - when, girl, are you going to be done with these reports?! That is my boss. The higher ups sign off on these things and ask about format, the format that has been there from Day 1. Does it make sense? Do I even notice it anymore? It has become routine. A routine that has outlived its usefulness.

Now Obama is talking about maybe, maybe, another Stimulus. Seriously? And combine that with tax cuts. Seriously???? What does this combination do - throw money on states and simultaneously take money away from the federal coffers? And this helps the deficit and the debt how exactly?? Even the Chinese must be wary by now.

Oh, they are political chess pieces to throw on the table in exchange for raising the debt limit. So we now have three, 3, trois, ways to continue to spend money we don't have. Stimulus #2. More tax cuts (keep cursing them as the Bush tax cuts). And raising the federal debt limit.

My only hope is that if we have Stimulus #2 that we can have meetings back at the old digs, cause its been awhile since I've had any chile cheese fritos.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Fact, Hope, Reality

Fact: Oregon has 10.6% unemployment.
Hope: That by focusing on the deficit (nationally), we can get our fiscal house in order and create jobs
Reality: Not likely in 3 months time. What is significant about 3 months? Thats when all those tea partiers and Republican voters get disenchanted, yet again, with the folks they voted in yesterday. Thats when things start looking up for Obama in 2012..

Fact: War spending - is it up to $1 Trillion, or $3 Trillion now? Remember how many B-1 bombers that is (a lot). Someone pointed out that a 10-year old has lived in a country where we have *always* been at war in Afghanistan. Somehow the term "war" loses its meaning when it is persistent.
Hope: The limited government types, will they address this? Weird as Rand Paul is sometimes, I think I heard him say military spending was fair game.
Reality: How many jobs in your congressional district depend on the military-industrial complex. Oh they Republicans claim they want to cut out earmarks. Well, except for those that impact their own constituents.
Patty Murray case in point - she is massively inspiring and I would want her for my senator. Maybe I should move to Washington, except for my little patch of land up there is 100% Rossi territory. Well, so what, I will pay my taxes and not put my car up on cement blocks or anything, so it should be ok. But she does bring home the bacon, and Washington has like 7 military bases. Hmm, Washington and its economic base is sounding better all the time..
But the reality here is that along with earmarks, and military spending, come jobs. And I don't think anyone, however principled, has the stomach or ill will to kill jobs right now.

Fact: Business uncertainty kills expansion, hiring, innovation.
Hope: Are tax cuts enough? If the lame duck Congress extends, even for a year, those Bush tax cuts, will this be enough certainty?
Reality: Confidence begets confidence. Here is a factoid - the Intel expansion in Hillsboro, which just may be (acc to our current Gov Kulongoski) the biggest industrial investment at $several billions, in the nation for the past two years. Well - Intel is able to take advantage of some $30B in Stimulus provided low interest bonds. Think again, dear Republican friends, before you think Stimulus is a 4-letter word.

Fact: Consumer spending is down.
Hope: Everyone can get back to living their lives, but, live within their means.
Reality: The Foreclosure mess is messing up a lot of people's lives, including those evil bankers. This will either take ages to work out, or, maybe something sensible can happen. Maybe allowing court-ordered "workouts", where a judge can mandate re-setting your home to current market rates. Instead of what you paid for the house which may have been a bubble-inflated price.

Fact: The Oregon Governor's race - done. I think. Dudley conceded. The vote tally is slightly ahead for Kitzhaber. But the votes aren't all counted yet...
Hope: Change for something new (back to the future type of new? Well, I guess some can be nostalgic for those glory days). Hey, one time I rode 7 floors in an elevator with-the-man-who-is-projected-to-be-the-next-Gov. Seemed like a regular guy. That was my 15 seconds of brush with fame.
Reality: To be written, day by day. Tomorrow may be Day 1.

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

How Stable is the State

HR 1586 was signed by Pres Obama yesterday. Known as either "aid to states" or "a state bailout" or a "jobs bill" or "payoff to the special interest teachers unions", it will provide $36 billion to states. Of this, $10 billion is for education, and $26 billion for Medicaid match.

OK a lot of states have been banking on this money. In Oregon I'm sure it will be helpful. What interesting tea leaves do we find lurking? To pass the bill in the House it had to be fully offset (every penny paid for). So I guess there will be no more "emergency" spending bills.

An emergency lets you spend money without the revenue to pay for it. Let's see, I will be taking the kids clothes shopping this afternoon, though I still owe on my credit cards and don't really have any spare money. And no taxing authority either much as I might like. But no doubt they will make it seem an emergency with school approaching quite soon, so spend I must.

But in Congress offsets are the new reality. Closing foreign tax loopholes, and scaling down food stamp benefits starting in 2014. Tricky how future savings can count as a way to pay for something today. Maybe Nordstrom Rack will take my IOU for "I promise not to go shopping next year, so I don't really have to pay for this blouse now do I?"

Oh and rescinding Stimulus money. This is a precedent. To help pay for this aid-to-states bill some of those unspent stimulus dollars have been rescinded, or taken back. Which I guess makes sense, if it was such an emergency why, 18 months after passage of the Stimulus bill, is there money still left on the table?

So, besides the political win for Democratic congresspeople as they flock home to enjoy the rest of their recess in their home sandboxes, will this money stabilize the states? It is another short term temporary infusion. Always deferring the ultimate fiscal reality till tomorrow, after that next election.

Saturday, June 26, 2010

The Day after the Day after

OK it was Thursday that HR 4213 died. Harry Reid pronounced its death. A little part of me still thinks the Senate could surprise us, maybe next week, maybe the week after that - when states feel they are sunk, when people have given up on unemployment extensions and soup kitchens start asking for more donations.

Did you know that disability claims go up when people lose unemployment? I can't say I understand the connection, but I've read this several places. Maybe when people feel they can get back to working they worry less about their own health and problems. Yes this happens, as soon as my mom took early retirement from DOD her health spiraled down and she died 7 years later. Hence I must keep working, even if it keeps the young ones out of the job market..

Lets look at levels of government and how they stand on deficits vs. continued stimulus:

Our Governor Kulongoski gave a talk yesterday, advocating fiscal austerity. He is finally engaged and plans to take his ideas to the state, traveling and campaigning for them. Maybe he will frame the debate for the 2 candidates to replace him - and start a dialog.

Reid and the U.S. Congress - the Republicans won their share of floor space, and the debate. The Dems, failing to garner even a single R vote, went down. So - deficit concern trumped continued stimulus.

Across the pond -the UK in their new "coalition" government is advocating new fiscal austerity. They are deathly afraid of being the next Greece. And are raising the Value Added Tax from 17% to 20%, as well as making cuts to various social welfare programs

Fourth and last example - the G8. I hear cries of fiscal austerity (today' s NY Times). I think Obama may be the lone voice advocating continued stimulus.

So lets take a tally:
Oregon - fiscal alarm
R's in Congress - fiscal alarm
UK - fiscal alarm
G8 - fiscal alarm
D's in Congress - stimulus

That makes 4:1, and is making me wonder..

Sunday, May 23, 2010

Is this a Second Stimulus?

“American Jobs and Closing Tax Loopholes Act of 2010” (Amendment to HR 4213, to be debated in both the House and Senate next week starting Tuesday, with an intent to pass it and have Obama sign by Memorial Day)


Brief overview:

$174B – spending (B = Billion)

$40B – offsets (revenue)

$134B net spending

(would you call this a second stimulus?)


Emergency spending (not subject to pay-go):

$47B – Unemployment extensions (currently cutoff at June 2, they would be extended to December 31, 2010. Note this does not add additional “tiers”, it only expands the cutoff dates. Once you’ve received your regular, 4 tiers of emergency, and extended benefits, That Is It – your 99 weeks).

$24B – FMAP extensions (federal Medicaid match)

$7.7B – Cobra extensions (federal 65% pickup)


Additional spending highlights:

$64B – Medicare “doc fix” (temporary 3-year continued higher reimbursement rates)

$19.6B – Business tax credits (R&D, AMT credit for domestic capital investment, leasehold cost recovery, economically distressed tax credits, other)

$5.0B – Tax credits for individuals (state/local tax deduction, property tax deduction, tuition deduction, teacher expense deduction)

$2.4B – Increase disaster loss expenditures (think Gulf Coast)

$1.4B – Agricultural supports (did you know we have both a Wool Trust Fund and a Cotton Trust Fund, supporting domestic industries?)

$1.3B – Alternative energy (biodiesel, biomass, heavy hybrids, liquid fuels (but not woody biomass aka black liquor as the OR delegation has been pushing), green homes, energy efficient windows, etc.)

$4.6B – Settlements (Cobell, Pigford) – Native American trust accounts, black farmer restitution

$10.9B – Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund – increase 8 cents/gallon tax to 32 cents/gallon to increase fund solvency in the case of, um, national oil disasters


Closing tax loopholes (revenue):

$14.3B – closing foreign tax loopholes

$18.6B – carried interest (instead of all hedge fund manager’s income being taxed at lower capital gains tax rate, some is taxed at income tax rate)

$9.6B – service professionals not exempt from social security income cap


Something for everyone? In the past, extensions to unemployment have been held up by Republicans over a lack of emergency designation. Now they are designated emergency (interesting how much weight a single word carries), does this mean no fighting and wasting Congressional floor time next week?